Volsung said:
@SC
Thanks! That was a very thorough explanation. I guess I should play ME1 to fully appreciate the second, which I did enjoy in fact. Mostly because I expected a glorified shooter but the game surprised me with good interesting narrative and a pretty cool setting.
I'm not a fan of the original Star Trek but I really like the Next Generation, so your examples were very helpful
Glad to help ^^
I'm mostly a fan of ST Voyager to be honest. Even tho there is only 1 true captain and it's Jean Luc Picard lol
Being a fan of both series, what other similarities did you find between ME and Star Trek?
Minor, almost nothing. I mean: sci fi genre has its common places, the universal translator, hyper-speed light devices and so on. Mass Effect System Alliance is basically the Federation of Planets, as you probably already noticed. Except that it's not human-centric and I like the discrimination between the Citadel Council species and the non-Council species. Star Trek is all human centric, typical of a childish writers\producers view. Humans are always good, loyal, intelligent and they always win no matter what. But you know, its was conceived in the 60s so, it's justified.
The Earth of Mass Effect is just a planet as any other and it's in ruin after multiple war holocausts and so on. The Earth story is not clear to be honest, I guess becoz it doesn't count too much. Humans are not in the Council before Shepard arrives and then there is Cerberus. Such an organization is beyond any Roddenberry's plan imo.
Krogans are a better version of Klingons. If the Kligon Empire fell in ruins for internal civil war (which it cyclically happens in truth) and fight among clans and a genetic artificial desease preventing them to reproduce at the pace of a rabbit, they could be the Krogans. Speak with one of them and you'll see the similarities: honor, war, being a honorable warrior, sacredness of battle and so on. But all the genophage story makes things even more interesting regarding the Krogans. That's my opinion.
Other than these, I cannot see much similarities between the two. Excepting those sci fi common places I told before. I said the Reapers are similar to the Borg in one sense. But the Borg don't pretend to be the rulers of the Galaxy, no matter how scary and powerful their menace is. Repears twisted plan is much more complicated and has interesting cosmologic and existential implications imo. There's no Hive: there're ancient powerful gods, sleeping for eons in the darkest space of the universe, waiting to come back and harvest. It's the Call of Chutulhu
One more thing that I appreciated a lot in ME2 is the creepy horror nuance it takes when exploring a Repear relict, same as in R. Scott's Alien. In ME1 the horror atmosphere was minor, even tho bloody horrorific quests don't lack.