Forums
Games
Cyberpunk 2077 Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales GWENT®: The Witcher Card Game The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher The Witcher Adventure Game
Jobs Store Support Log in Register
Forums - CD PROJEKT RED
Menu
Forums - CD PROJEKT RED
  • Hot Topics
  • NEWS
  • GENERAL
    SUGGESTIONS
  • STORY
    MAIN JOBS SIDE JOBS GIGS
  • GAMEPLAY
  • TECHNICAL
    PC XBOX PLAYSTATION
  • COMMUNITY
    FAN ART (THE WITCHER UNIVERSE) FAN ART (CYBERPUNK UNIVERSE) OTHER GAMES
  • RED Tracker
    The Witcher Series Cyberpunk GWENT
MAIN JOBS
SIDE JOBS
GIGS
Menu

Register

[Spoiler Alert] About the endings

+

Do you want more RPGs with happy endings?

  • Yes, I miss happy endings.

    Votes: 492 42.6%
  • No, I am content with the endings currently offered.

    Votes: 115 10.0%
  • I think that the option should be available for those who want it.

    Votes: 343 29.7%
  • It’s more complicated than that.

    Votes: 205 17.7%

  • Total voters
    1,155
Prev
  • 1
  • …

    Go to page

  • 430
  • 431
  • 432
  • 433
  • 434
  • …

    Go to page

  • 753
Next
First Prev 432 of 753

Go to page

Next Last
E

Eakani

Forum regular
#8,621
Dec 30, 2020
Willowhugger said:
1. There's a lot of lost tech out there and other megacorps than Arasaka, which has been unable to replicate what Alt Cunningham created BY HERSELF with Soulkiller 50 years ago. It's not actually as advanced a corporation as they think it is.

2. Eh, you have literally all time the time in the world. Cloning is also a thing in the universe.
Click to expand...

Good points, i only hope that CDPR is also as creative as you ;)
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: Willowhugger
trapromance

trapromance

Fresh user
#8,622
Dec 30, 2020
There is a possibility that given the creator of CP being on board with CDPR's development team, V might very likely be on the path to becoming the first fully cyberized human in the Cyberpunk universe. There are a lot of cues as to the inevitability of it happening, given the endings are left open-ended (believe me, 6 months is actually a long time to go on in an RPG setting); the Alt ending may actually be implicative of this being where it's headed.

Cloning technology exists in in the PnP Cyberpunk, it's advanced, but we're not talking 'Star Wars' levels of advanced. V is on borrowed time, and 6 months is simply not enough for that option.

Adam Smasher was almost completely cyberized save for his brain, and that was all through Arasaka Technology.

Multiple endings are actually implicating that the NUSA is getting involved, who are confirmed to be leagues above Arasaka in terms of technological and military prowess. Both current lore and PnP lore actually states that should the NUSA want it, they could wipe out all of the Corporations in the CP setting. It would be unwise to do so, however, because it would permanently damage the infrastructure of the country. Other global superpowers exist outside of the US.

I now suspect that we're getting a GITS treatment of V. Motoko Kusanagi was actually very capable of having intimate, physical relationships with people, if any one is concerned about that.
 
Willowhugger

Willowhugger

Forum veteran
#8,623
Dec 30, 2020
I will also apologize for while I think that two of the endings have you survive, I also am sick of "The hero dies" endings.

* Fallout 3
* Mass Effect 3
* Bioshock Infinite's DLC
* RDR

Is there a reason so many games are in love with these?
 
I_Willenbrock_I

I_Willenbrock_I

Senior user
#8,624
Dec 30, 2020
Willowhugger said:
Eh it's a power fantasy. Therefore, I'm inclined to think we're meant to view it through the lens of hope.

V could end up gunned down in the streets the next day but we expect that he won't because that's the nature of storytelling.

Its like Blade Runner's director's cut. Will Rachel die in 4 years? Or will they find hope?



1. There's a lot of lost tech out there and other megacorps than Arasaka, which has been unable to replicate what Alt Cunningham created BY HERSELF with Soulkiller 50 years ago. It's not actually as advanced a corporation as they think it is.

2. Eh, you have literally all time the time in the world. Cloning is also a thing in the universe.
Click to expand...
Only one company is able to create clones - biotechnica.
In addition, cloning is illegal in all parts of the world.

However. After arasakas push with relic 2.0, other companies might be willing to ignore that, because it would be lucrative to sell blank mind clones to rich people, so they don't have to sacrifice close relatives.

The perfect joint venture...

Its an option but one that only works in combination with a stable relic 2.0, an engram, a clone and time..
 
Simuxas

Simuxas

Senior user
#8,625
Dec 30, 2020
Willowhugger said:
I think they assumed that people with the Nomad or Araska ending believed V would survive. They don't think that gamers who have witnessed their characters gun down 1000s of thugs will fail in their mission to survive.

Basically, they royally underestimated gamer cynicism.

And that is, admittedly, on them,
Click to expand...
Its not much on player cynycism, its just shitty endings trying to be ambiguous. But they arent, they just edgy and shitty.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: JuanEvil, General_Aegis, Anrix1 and 1 other person
Willowhugger

Willowhugger

Forum veteran
#8,626
Dec 30, 2020
trapromance said:
I now suspect that we're getting a GITS treatment of V.
Click to expand...
I think an interesting question is whether gamers would accept a Uploaded V is the "Real" V as that's entirely possible with Soulkiller and putting them in a new body via a chip as we see with Johnny. He was created with technology that's 50 years old and as much as an asshole as he is, there's no sign he's not 100% a perfect reproduction of Johnny if not actually the real thing.

Especially since Cyberspace in Mike Pondsmith's world isn't servers and farms but a literal alternate dimension that people tap into (which is fucking weird but it was the Eighties).
 
I_Willenbrock_I

I_Willenbrock_I

Senior user
#8,627
Dec 31, 2020
Willowhugger said:
I will also apologize for while I think that two of the endings have you survive, I also am sick of "The hero dies" endings.

* Fallout 3
* Mass Effect 3
* Bioshock Infinite's DLC
* RDR

Is there a reason so many games are in love with these?
Click to expand...
Mass effect 3 is a very poor example, because the company was grilled for that games endi g and never really came back after it.

It was poor and shoddy writing and admittedly cobbled together by hack Casey Hudson within a few days, because they had absolutely no idea how to end the game.
In addition, they changed the endings...

Rdr series ist also different, because your death is set in stone, unlike V's fate. In fact, we safe V in several of the endings and still die, because of a lousy plot device, wich doesn't serve any real purpose, except invoking a very negative reaction.

Fallout 3s endi g was retconned in a dlc.

In bioshock infinite, nothing really made sense, so it was ok.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: arcsirc
lolic99

lolic99

Forum regular
#8,628
Dec 31, 2020
Willowhugger said:
I will also apologize for while I think that two of the endings have you survive, I also am sick of "The hero dies" endings.

* Fallout 3
* Mass Effect 3
Click to expand...
Not really.
In the first, the hero survives in game with DLC.
In the second - in the red ending and certain conditions.

Once upon a time, drama was in vogue, but it really fucked up the players and does not pay off well.
 
Ycare

Ycare

Fresh user
#8,629
Dec 31, 2020
Many people already said it, but the entire story arc was about "Change", "Evolving", "Accepting to move on". This was a theme so recurring that I could feel one of the ending coming crystal clear: a way to "merge" Johnny and V, thus becoming a new person, having come to terms with the fact that this relic changed you for better or worse.

Honestly, I had made my peace with this path halfway through the game, and was ready to accept becoming part Johnny, part me, it even made me reflect on what makes "you" who you are.

But nope, it was about accepting death or denying it till the bitter end. Nothing to do with "Change/Evolution". Quite the opposite. A totally missed opportunity.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: General_Aegis
lolic99

lolic99

Forum regular
#8,630
Dec 31, 2020
Willowhugger said:
I think an interesting question is whether gamers would accept a Uploaded V is the "Real" V as that's entirely possible with Soulkiller and putting them in a new body via a chip as we see with Johnny.
Click to expand...
Adequate players will accept. And dreamers can continue to build delusional theories about copying.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: TintelFruit
E

Eakani

Forum regular
#8,631
Dec 31, 2020
Willowhugger said:
I think an interesting question is whether gamers would accept a Uploaded V is the "Real" V as that's entirely possible with Soulkiller and putting them in a new body via a chip as we see with Johnny. He was created with technology that's 50 years old and as much as an asshole as he is, there's no sign he's not 100% a perfect reproduction of Johnny if not actually the real thing.

Especially since Cyberspace in Mike Pondsmith's world isn't servers and farms but a literal alternate dimension that people tap into (which is fucking weird but it was the Eighties).
Click to expand...
Alt already used soulkiller to extract and seperate V and Johnny. So the question is already there, is it still the "Real V" because it is the original body, or is "Real V" already gone because of the use of soulkiller?

I like the idea to save V with a new body, seems like the most logical way to save him/her.
 
kabalfs

kabalfs

Fresh user
#8,632
Dec 31, 2020
proxyrev said:
6,539 messages, 327 pages. Don't give up guys, can't really be ignored at this point la :ok: !! We might eventually get a response/statement sooner than later, a "we're working on it" at least, hopefully :shrug:
Click to expand...
I'm writing at over 430 pages and you have no idea how much I want this to be true...
 
lolic99

lolic99

Forum regular
#8,633
Dec 31, 2020
Eakani said:
Alt already used soulkiller to extract and seperate V and Johnny. So the question is already there, is it still the "Real V" because it is the original body, or is "Real V" already gone because of the use of soulkiller?
Click to expand...
There is no such question in the game, it was brought from somewhere else.
This is the real V. How real a digital projection of consciousness can be.
This is Cyberpunk, not Soma. Calm down already.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: TintelFruit
onosendai7

onosendai7

Senior user
#8,634
Dec 31, 2020
lolic99 said:
Adequate players will accept. And dreamers can continue to build delusional theories about copying.
Click to expand...
I consider the engram as a perfect copy of V's mind went it is done -it's also sold that way by Arasaka. However, by introducing the "soul" stuff, CDPR totally invalidate that. The soul decays (lol) and thus, the copy becomes more and more degraded.
And curiously, they build a story in which a 60 year old engram is simply changing and evolving, regaining some humanity, acknowledging his failures and quelling his pride. Becoming human, sort of.
The only delisional theory about copying is CDPR's.
Post automatically merged: Dec 31, 2020

Willowhugger said:
Especially since Cyberspace in Mike Pondsmith's world isn't servers and farms but a literal alternate dimension that people tap into (which is fucking weird but it was the Eighties).
Click to expand...
Nope.
I think you misunderstood.
 
lolic99

lolic99

Forum regular
#8,635
Dec 31, 2020
onosendai7 said:
I consider the engram as a perfect copy of V's mind went it is done -it's also sold that way by Arasaka.
Click to expand...
This is V's consciousness. This is how it works in terms of game mechanics.
onosendai7 said:
The only delisional theory about copying is CDPR's.
Click to expand...
Maybe. They were smart enough not to explain how it works. For which too zealous players immediately took up.
 
onosendai7

onosendai7

Senior user
#8,636
Dec 31, 2020
I_Willenbrock_I said:
Let's be honest.
If a lot... Like a really lot of people in here are finding inconsistencies, plot problems, contradictions and have a massive lack of closure, because a silly and unnecessary plot device kills you no matter how you decide, the ending is not satisfying.

It is not satisfying, if you want more. That's the opposite.
Click to expand...
Nope, it's not satisfying because all the flaws you write. Also because no matter the road you take, you're still at Roma in the end. This is not roleplaying, this is railroad playing.
I don't want "more". I accept the bad ending in the Witcher 3 because it is logic, it is not against the character of the world and it is fitting for a desperate Geralt.
In CP2077, CDPR make a giant middlefinger to the players. Nothing less.

I_Willenbrock_I said:
We should be in here and discussing why we have chosen our ending and not why the endinds don't make sense and are poorly written in relation to the rest of the story (small pacing mistakes aside).
Click to expand...
I have chosen the endings cause they are there. Not because they are interesting, or fulfilling or anything else, but simply because this is the endgame and there is one way to go.
Besides, there is no choice. They're all the same :
- die now (suicide / going with alt / believing Arasaka has become a philanthropic company)
- die in 6 month (nope, there is no cure my cute desert rat )
The only open ending is the space one. Playing that run is the thing I want. Or it is also the costliest way to commit suicide...
Post automatically merged: Dec 31, 2020

lolic99 said:
They were smart enough not to explain how it works. For which too zealous players immediately took up.
Click to expand...
This is not smart. This is lazy.
Besides, there are 30 years of gaming stuff explaining what it is. CDPR simply chose to reject the background to serve a somewhat bad story.
 
lolic99

lolic99

Forum regular
#8,637
Dec 31, 2020
onosendai7 said:
This is not smart. This is lazy.
Besides, there are 30 years of gaming stuff explaining what it is. CDPR simply chose to reject the background to serve a somewhat bad story.
Click to expand...
It is impossible with the current level of technology to clearly "explain" how it works. Especially not for scientists but for simple players. This is a convention to be accepted. Like the existence of a time machine or hyperdrive. Instead of pretending to be Einsteins.
Post automatically merged: Dec 31, 2020

onosendai7 said:
die in 6 month (nope, there is no cure my cute desert rat )
The only open ending is the space one.
Click to expand...
6 months is a completely open ending for me.
There is no need to rush and kill your character. You can still do all kinds of nonsense in the city. Or go through the story, but first saved in many slots.
Then wait for the dlc with the ending and go through it for real.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: TintelFruit and naddaya
arcsirc

arcsirc

Forum regular
#8,638
Dec 31, 2020
lolic99 said:
Adequate players will accept. And dreamers can continue to build delusional theories about copying.
Click to expand...
i know which of those two titles i'd rather be labelled with
Post automatically merged: Dec 31, 2020

trapromance said:
There is a possibility that given the creator of CP being on board with CDPR's development team, V might very likely be on the path to becoming the first fully cyberized human in the Cyberpunk universe. There are a lot of cues as to the inevitability of it happening, given the endings are left open-ended (believe me, 6 months is actually a long time to go on in an RPG setting); the Alt ending may actually be implicative of this being where it's headed.
Click to expand...
oooh hope not, I want to be a hedonistic meatbag if i'm living in night city
 
Last edited: Dec 31, 2020
E

Eakani

Forum regular
#8,639
Dec 31, 2020
lolic99 said:
There is no such question in the game, it was brought from somewhere else.
This is the real V. How real a digital projection of consciousness can be.
This is Cyberpunk, not Soma. Calm down already.
Click to expand...
There are no such questions like "Is uploaded life, still life?" or "Is the uploaded being still the same?" in the game? Aha...

I only made clear, if people really have a problem with an uploaded consciousness for their character, it would be a problem, cause it already happend. Thats it.

I am totally calm, maybe you should check your attitude.
 
Last edited: Dec 31, 2020
Willowhugger

Willowhugger

Forum veteran
#8,640
Dec 31, 2020
onosendai7 said:
Besides, there is no choice. They're all the same :
- die now (suicide / going with alt / believing Arasaka has become a philanthropic company)
- die in 6 month (nope, there is no cure my cute desert rat )
The only open ending is the space one. Playing that run is the thing I want. Or it is also the costliest way to commit suicide...
Click to expand...
Repeating this doesn't make it true. Why do you keep saying this?

1. Nomad: You go off to find a cure and according to the player's desire, probably do.
2. Arasaka: You become immortal.

It doesn't make any sense and is just weird.
 
Last edited: Dec 31, 2020
  • RED Point
Reactions: TintelFruit and Motsie
Prev
  • 1
  • …

    Go to page

  • 430
  • 431
  • 432
  • 433
  • 434
  • …

    Go to page

  • 753
Next
First Prev 432 of 753

Go to page

Next Last
Share:
Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Link
  • English
    English Polski (Polish) Deutsch (German) Русский (Russian) Français (French) Português brasileiro (Brazilian Portuguese) Italiano (Italian) 日本語 (Japanese) Español (Spanish)

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook Twitter YouTube
CDProjekt RED
  • Contact administration
  • User agreement
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookie policy
  • Press Center
© 2018 CD PROJEKT S.A. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

CD PROJEKT®, Cyberpunk®, Cyberpunk 2077® are registered trademarks of CD PROJEKT S.A. © 2018 CD PROJEKT S.A. All rights reserved. All other copyrights and trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Forum software by XenForo® © 2010-2020 XenForo Ltd.