Did we play the same game?
Judy didn't suggest for Evelyn to go back to Clouds, she just didn't stop her. Going back was Evelyn's idea and choice.
Did you miss the part where Finger was groping/raping the women he worked on? Yeah, he didn't take their money, great guy -_-
Leaving the Killer Doll program intact would have caused problems. First it would have made the Dolls a power themselves, the other gangs and Corps wouldn't allow that to exist. In addition, if anyone becomes aware how easy it is to reprogram the dolls, everyone would do it, the Dolls would lose.
Judy also doesn't want to be in charge, but create a community that will rule itself (democracy?). That's why she asks the Dolls to fight for themselves. Just like the Moxes have done.
The reason why Judy left is because Night City is a city of lies. Viktor realized that and adjusted his life accordingly. Judy wants stability, a family, people to rely on. Is that childish?
So Judy is childish for accomplishing her goal of taking Clouds from the Claws with a crazy Killer-Doll plan that backfires. But Panam is wise for accomplishing her goal of taking down an AV with a crazy plan that backfires.
Yes we play the same game, but obviously have different perspectives.
Night City is not a kind place, not only lies, but cruel and real.
The people live there are not simple human, but a monster.
Organ trading, murder, drugs, countless evil, Night City lose 30% population a year.
Sex crime is a light one, even would not be count as a crime.
Yes Finger is definitely sucked, but he is the less evil. And there is only less evil and big evil at NC.
To find a good guy? Have you realized most of the good guys you know suffered?
BTW, does V really know a guy who is totally clean and good?
First of all, V and Jackie are criminal, Jackie die at a robbery.
Shall I going on?
Yes, Leaving the Killer Doll program intact would have caused problems.
And that's we called responsibility. If there is no any risk, no bad ending waiting, everyone can be a hero.
Face the risk, know the doll's future is on your hand, and use the power to create the future you need.
The dolls give you trust to control Cloud, that's means give their life and future to you.
And Judy just says, dolls will take care of themselves and remove their weapon.
How can they protect themselves with no weapons? By say you can do it?
Mox do it because they fight at beginning and win without the special weapon like Killer Doll program.
If you don't want to be in charge, leave power as far as you can. Because it's a dangerous fire.
BTW, Find Democracy at Night City without weapon? Are Claws looks like someone would listen the theory of great democracy and trust it?
You can't only judge the things by result. Judy is childish because she can't see the real world and understand how to make things right. The good hope she want is an illusion from the start.
And I will say it again, that's pure golden heart also a part of her charm. I'm no doubt that many people will be touched. That's proof of CDPR complete this charactor well. If there is something piss me off, that's CDPR refuse to let V to control Cloud, which is a resonable way to keep it safe and better, at least the time in game.