I don't agree with every single point, but I agree with most of them.
But it is quite apparent that most of the people who enjoy this game are the people who only care about the story. Gameplay is something they don't know how to value. They don't know what good gameplay feels like. It's your typical casuals.
If you enjoy the game for what it is, fine. But I hard disagree with anyone who calls this game a "masterpiece". That's my opinion anyway.
And, sorry, but it's an elitist opinion - basically doing the same as, say, hardcore fans of Radiohead who look down on others who like 'Creep'.
Calling 'fake fan' on people just because you think they sink fewer hours in than you, that their opinion matters less than yours but also ruins your experience by causing CDPR to dumb down - it's alienating a wider audience that is sorely needed.
Gaming is a healthy pastime for most of us, and doing it more than others doesn't mean you're somehow better. If that
is your currency, though, I'm more than happy to lay down my 29 years of nigh-on daily games-playing as collateral.
I'm enjoying most elements of the game and am really looking forward to seeing it improve because the people at CDPR don't come into work (or log on) to do a crap job. I'm astonished, frankly, at what they were able to produce working remotely, with all the constraints etc that that entailed. Not to mention the pressure from the unreasonable suits who clearly understand nothing of development (
that is CDPR's biggest crime, in addition to the last-gen console debacle).
That doesn't mean it's perfect, but I typically laugh at the stuff that's broken or incomplete - because that stuff's funny, and
it's only a game. I work around it, have a laugh or a little sigh, and move on; because life's too short.
When the game falls a bit short in 'immersion' (a term I absolutely despise, but I use because people know what I mean), my imagination fills in the blanks, because, like all art, you have to be prepared to bring something to the table to complete the experience.
There are glimpses of the potential there: enough for me to see what it is they intend to achieve, so I'm willing to be patient, and to carry on playing regardless. With CDPR's history of swathing changes after release (Witcher 3 was unrecognisable after a year), this could be the last time of being able to play it in its current form, so why not? There's shonkiness and incomplete or 'immersion-breaking' stuff in every game. So what?
I might play less regularly (playthrough #1 is at 100 hrs now, though: is that enough?), but I'm going to keep coming back because
not to do so would be to cut off my nose to spite my face.
It also means a much happier life all-round!