Michael Graf: Before I get to Inquisition, I have to state the following: 87 points for Dragon Age 2 is for me one of the most absurd verdicts Gamestar has ever given to a game. Although it was not nearly as abysmal as it is often made the simplified game mechanics, the shallow kawuum fights, the lazy dungeon recycling and the main story that didn't really got interesting before the last third - all that wasn't worthy of the magnificent Dragon Age: Origins. Dragon Age 2 was a game in which you painfully clearly noticed how little time and love Bioware wanted to invest into it. Or were allowed to.
That's different with Inquisition. They put time and love into it, especially into the game world. Compared to Dragon Age 2 it is undoubtedly the better game. Nevertheless, it gets a worse score, how can that be? Because we at Gamestar believe that we shouldn't carry around every mistake we ever made. Because we have the opinion that an overrated predecessor shouldn't serve as an excuse forever for giving better scores to its successorss. The only thing that should justify a good review is gameplay quality.
And unquestionably Inquisition has its qualities, especially its sheer size, its flood of adventures. In a time in which you must call yourself lucky not to get sold every quest individually as DLC such a colossus is even more appreciated. It's enough reason alone to buy Inquisition. There is - besides the menus - nothing that I would describe as outright 'bad'. The narrative entertains, the dialogues are neat, the characters and stories are more sophisticated than in most other games. And the dragons are just terrific! Yes, Inquisition is an all around great game. Period.
But it's just not as outstanding as Origins. The series' grandfather had even better stories, even more memorable moments, even more memorable characters, it offered real struggles and a tactical system that a classical RPG actually deserves. And by the way it was also controllable on the PC without getting finger cramps. Sure, Inquisition has new strengths - but those are not the strengths of Dragon Age. I like it anyway, very much so, and I will happily continue to play it after the review to reveal its last secret, its final reward, its last dragon in this fantastic world. And I won't regret any second of it.