If it comes to that, I vote, kill snowwhite.Seeker said:It more of a matter of the Lesser Evil
If it comes to that, I vote, kill snowwhite.Seeker said:It more of a matter of the Lesser Evil
Nevertheless... I will never let her burn because I don't like fanatics and mob law, especially when they have their skeleton in the closet... as Seeker says.TheSilver said:Personally, in the few runthroughs I have done, I've never felt comfortable leaving Abigail to the villagers wrath. I perfectly see that each side could be guilty and/or a combination of both. However, I also believe in situations affecting behaviour and numerous chances.That means the next time, Abigail will burn :evil:
I'm With Petra on this I will never let her burn as well for the same reasons as well I dont like Zealot for the most part they get everyone killed but themselves .PetraSilie said:Nevertheless... I will never let her burn because I don't like fanatics and mob law, especially when they have their skeleton in the closet... as Seeker says.PetraSilie said:Personally, in the few runthroughs I have done, I've never felt comfortable leaving Abigail to the villagers wrath. I perfectly see that each side could be guilty and/or a combination of both. However, I also believe in situations affecting behaviour and numerous chances.That means the next time, Abigail will burn :evil:
The Only reason I'd let her burn is to see how it happens and check the consequences. Why would you do something over again that you know is wrong?? :whatthe:It's complete foolishness hidden as Nonsense...Seeker said:I'm With Petra on this I will never let her burn as well...for the same reasons as well I dont like Zealot for the most part they get everyone killed but themselves .Seeker said:Nevertheless... I will never let her burn because I don't like fanatics and mob law, especially when they have their skeleton in the closet... as Seeker says.Seeker said:That means the next time, Abigail will burn :evil:
I don't think soLDiCesare said:So, unless we make the ridiculous assumption that this is all a game and for game design reasons the witch had to live, it seems to me that Abigail is innocent of the Beast but if you save her, she probably murders the old witch to take her place.
Indeed it seems the most likely.Enidehalas said:Don't think so, peasants say that the old healer died during last winter and no one took her place, until Abigail cameI think it's just a game conveniance. Or that if Abigail don't come, they fetch the first healer they find, even if it's an old hag xD
My memory of the conversation is that the gang of would-be rapists was told to wait for something Salamander-related, and they decide to rape Shani to pass the time while they're waiting for whatever this other thing is. Some people would pass the time by playing cards or something, but these are professional thugs....rhufus said:Concerning Mikul being responsible for the Rape of Ilsa - If you go back to the dialoge in the tavern; one of the Rapists makes a comment to Geralt asking if he was told to wait like the rest (or something to that effect); This leads me to believe that the leader of the rapist mob was not present yet for the rape of Shani; If the leader was NOT Mikul, who could it have been.