I concur with those voicing their dislike of auto-refills. That is just too easy and convenient. I know you guys at CDPR are trying to appeal to a wider audience, but even those new to the series will appreciate mechanics that reward thinking, planning, and generally making an effort, though perhaps not immediately. And please do not forget about the fans that loved and supported your previous games. We want a meaningful evolution in the gameplay, not simplification and overt streamlining.
I was thinking the same. My fear is that now that they are getting far more popular than by the release of the two previous games they are "adjusting" some things (witcher sense showing where to climb :rly?for more casual gamers and newcomers to the series. Tough time for us hardcore witcher fans coming?
Not just here. Traditional or oldschool-type RPG'ers in general. It's not getting any better elsewhere either aside from few shoelacebudget indies from crowdfunding campaigns.
Please do.
Last edited:
what king of underwater combat sistem would you see let's be real .....give me one example of an underwater combat sistem, its to hard to make one, the crosbow/ harpoon gun is the easyest option, the alternativ would be no combat at all
Well, you have to consider that CDPR is getting a whole new console audience (new to the series) they want to please.
That and the fact that they want to make their revolutionary RPG game available and accessible for everyone
is responsible for the overall down-dumbing of gameplay elements.
You know, as long as we don't need to mount flak cannons to hunt griffins it'll be ok.
If an option is easy it does not make it sensible. And how exactly would a harpoon gun work in the Witcher's timeline? And you simply do not have the materials to make a crossbow efficient underwater.
There IS a big difference between notes about behaviours and weaknesses of monsters in your journal and recommended item. For the former you actually need your brain to sort out which potions might be suited best for what you know about the monster the latter is made for braindead people....
This is casualization at its best, sorry. I don't like that. At all.
That's a horrible mindset to have. It's what got BioWare to where they are.
This is the impression I got from Konrad's interviews, especially his latest one which was posted recentely. It may be even more severe in Witcher games as opposed to other RPGs, because potions are somewhat integral to the lore.
They can accommodate anyone they want, just don't forget where you started from. PC gamers made this franchise what it is, don't screw your main demographic over with non-sensical systems.
Your intuition never fails, wichat.
Hopefully high toxicity will have side-effects, just like the radiation level in Fallout 3.
Both visually (hallucinations, etc..) and affecting the stats of the character~
That's it. If there absolutely NEEDS to be ranged combat underwater, the signs would be the best solution, albeit still not a good one. Crossbow just doesn't make any sense whatsoever, these things simply don't work underwater. And there's no other ranged underwater weapon I'm aware of that would fit the technological level of the world we're playing in.
I don't see a problem with melee combat only though and I'm not quite sure why that should be a problem from a game-play or programming perspective either.
I was thinking the same. My fear is that now that they are getting far more popular than by the release of the two previous games they are "adjusting" some things (witcher sense showing where to climb :rly?
There is a way to make both crowds happy, and that is adjustable difficulty, something like the new Thief game. Basically, you choose what features you want or do not want. So for example we could choose if we want our potions to be refilling with or without reagents consumption.
That would be something to consider. Not just regarding the potions but also how "strong" the witcher sense is for example and other features. But as Marcin said, it's all WIP and even if it stays that way, there'll hopefully be an EE where they can change things.
OMG. That is so wrong. As well as auto-replenishing. Really hoping that this experiment will be declined in next months before release.
Well, theoretically you could heat up the water enough to cause pain/damage to your enemies. After all, it's MAGIC! As I said, it's not great but certainly better than crossbows/harpoons.
I think it's important to understand that complete realism =/= fun. Sure, certain people would love to play Witcher 3 - The Real Life in a Fantasy World Simulator, but most don't. For such reasons, CDPR doesn't include hunger mechanisms, or the need to go to the bathroom or some other stupid shit like that.
Perhaps this system isn't the most realistic, and might break immersion for a few poor souls out there, but if it is properly executed - it could fix a problem without dumbing down or simplifying anything.