They need AO rating!
I also think you're a bit biased against Nilfgaard and make it sound worse than it really is. Emhyr and his entourage didn't seem THAT bad to me. I actually really liked General Voorhis. He's probably the nicest guy in Nilfgaard and he'd make a good husband for Ciri if she indeed marries him.
The open-ended nature of the endings kind of makes it so they can be anything that you want and my vision of the future is no more valid than yours, @luc0s .
So, g'head.
I actually think Nilfgaard is a pretty awesome place to live, being as it's a First World Nation compared to the Third World Nation of the North. I also think that once Emhyr is dead, the Nilfgaard will probably cease their campaigns of aggressive expansion and conquest over anything that moves. If we can get less Emhyrs, Radovids, and Henselts then the world can be a better place I think.
I think I have a very unromantic view of the nobility in the Witcherverse. They're routinely portrayed as selfish, shallow, short-sighted, subject to constant manipulations, and often terminally stupid. Ciri is none of those things but I think it's the rare one which rises above that sort of thing and these are the kind of people she'll deal with. Let's face it, the Bloody Baron and Foltest are the two best nobles we meet and they're both objectively terrible people.
The Witcher was a choice between the arrogant nobility of the Flaming Rose and the desperate mean-spirited peasants of the Scoia'tale. I think, like Westeros, the Witcher does a good job of de-romanticizing the concept of hereditary nobility as well as the past 1000 years of romanticizing it. I do think that if Yennefer is Ciri's advisor that things will be much-much happier for her, though, as Yennefer and Ciri would be an unbeatable team and she wouldn't be surrounded by fawning scyopants and strangers. Yennefer would also probably make it possible for Ciri to have the kind of advice she needs and freedom to grow as a person.
I don't think Geralt would ever be happy in Nilfgaard, though, because he'd be just a glorified bodyguard at best and constantly in the middle of intrigues (Not that he isn't already--now that I think about it). The big deal I'd see is Emhyr would want access to HIS daughter and would try to drive Geralt as well as Yennefer away.
The Witcher ending is one Ciri, herself, wanted to choose.
I guess I was really moved by Ciri's Witcher speech in Blood of Elves where she wanted to be one because they were champions of justice and that it was a freedom she could rejoice in. I was really touched on the "travelling actors" troupe mission where Ciri looked back at a couple kissing and said, "I want that."
I knew I'd have to try and give that to her.
Ironically, I think Ciri would be just fine as Queen of Skellige or a smaller nation like that. Nilfgaard, though, is the kind of place which obsesses over how you bow. In the eternal war of Slobs vs. Snobs, Ciri is firmly on the side of the Slobs.
Can't argue with that logic. But ultimately it's not about what you want to give to her, it's what Ciri wants. And the fact of the matter is that what Ciri wants depends on the information she has. If she's aware of her claim to the Nilfgaardian throne, she will want to become empress. If Ciri is unaware of her claim to the Nilfgaardian throne, she stick to her desire to become a witcher.
My only rebuttal was that Ciri asked my Geralt's opinion of going to meet her and I said that Emhyr would try to manipulate her.
And I got the Witcher ending.
So I think they're about equally honest. It depends really on what Geralt's opinion of Emhyr is versus any free choice of Ciris.
Fair enough. I didn't know about that. I thought that if you choose to tell Ciri about Emhyr she'll always want to go there.
I told Ciri that Emhyr might not be the best man but he is her father so the very least she could do is hear him out, and then I got the empress Ciri ending.
Guys I'm watching again the Official Launch trailer and I see there is a scene with Yen which wasn't in the game
Yen is watching Geralt training Ciri....why did they cut it out?
I like that smile...
This thread is not about Ciri but ok. Do you know that in books Emgyr married Ciri in the end? Not true one but her clone. And at the lodge sorceress told Ciri she can't be queen anymore. Even in Kovir she can be only prince favourite concubine. So the end with her been Empress isn't very lore friendly. Also it would be hard for her to rule the Empire as you know from the books and ingame messages Nilfgard nobles were against Emgyr marriage with Ciri. Instead they wanted him to married one of the Niflgard noble woman not some outlander. So don't expect easy life for Ciri as Empress. In fact after Emgyr death it's more likely that nobles will kill her and make new king from Nilfgard.
And I think it was a good decision. It has never happened it was just a dream of Geralt. He even says that it was funny that instead Triss there was Yennefer there in his dream. So there is no need for this scene because it's not really Yennefer but just reflection of her in Geralt mind. I barely accept whole concept of dream about Yennefer Ciri and Geralt in Kaer Morhen as it should be Triss there. But if this is only a dream and not memories... well it could be but still I find it strange. Though I understand their wish to introduce Yennefer and Ciri early in the game and there is no such moment in the books when all 3 were together. So they came up for this trick with dream.
Been observing Triss and Yen's thread on this forum for quite a while.
Most of Yen fanboys are open; we discuss not just about Yen but it expands to Geralt and Ciri. Then we moved on to how Yennefer would influence Ciri and Yen's potential role if there were to be more witcher games in the future. To top it up, there's even some fan art in this thread
Triss fanboys? Well, they're not happy with all the attention Yen is getting in the game lol. So their discussion mostly revolved around blaming yen, arguing Geralt is better off with Triss and rage about the lack of Triss content (which I have to agree). I pity the Triss fanboys
As much as I love Triss, her contents seems like a distance future to me... (though Triss might be the 'perfect' match for Geralt after all).
Pretty sure we're all tired about talking the Empty world after the ending. How much longer do we have to wait for an announcement or hints like 'Due to fan's complaint, we are working for a solution to bring back Yen and Triss...... we 'kinda, sorta' overlooked the that fans would totally be hooked up with the game. sorry for being an ass. Love, CDPR"
Willowhugger, just reading your review of Blood of Elves. (Great review btw.) Are you planning to read also the rest of the Witcher books?
I've already read them! Just haven't reviewed em.
And yes, all of them will be reviewed!
I also was trying to figure out some essays on the game to do.
I just want to ask generally, in your opinion... do you think Witcher 3 is really the end of Geralt? because there are too many unanswered questions.
If there is a potential, how many more Witcher games should CDPR come out with before they really should retire it from the shelf?