Okay let me get this straight. Only because something fits for me in the Atmosphere of an Game(in this case Witcher 3 and the new armors), you want talk down my Opinion to simply: "that i don't understand what the role of Atmosphere is". Good grief, this discuss gets even worse.
I mean, it seems you simply doesn't understand what i mean. I said, maybe they could've done it better. Like i said, how - as example, would it have been, if they left out the Armor completly untouched, until you reach BaW and when you want to to change the Color of this Armor(aka dye) the smith have to overhaul the armor so it dyeable. That would be more lorefriendly and simple for people who wants to stick to the old Armor-Design, or a bit easier, they should've added an Option (like someone already suggested). However where i'm against at is that People like you claim their own tastes/opinion as FACT, and comes with an argument like Realistic, Lore, History or Atmosphere. You CANT simply generalize FOR ALL OF US, what fits the Atmosphere of Witcher 3, its UP TO EACH THEIR OWN to decide what fits the atmosphere. And thats the Point why i argue with you Guys. Because for me it still fits Witcher 3 - even the Main Game and doesn't break the Atmosphere/immersion.