I think it's fair to test the waters and to consider a sub-genre of sci-fi as something niche, let alone cyberpunk, and cyberpunk in probably its purest form. In general I think that fantasy is much more popular than sci-fi or that unadulterated, hard sci-fi. A lot of the most popular sci-fi franchises are closer to fantasy with a futuristic coat of paint. Cyberpunk itself has seen a drift from something harsher, grayer, dirtier and political to something that is more about technology... while some of the most popular versions of the genre (and others like Steampunk) are often audulterated with magic, because it's either easier to write or easier to understand or both than technobabble (even if completely made up). A game that is a throwback to the original 80s style of cyberpunk may not have been as popular. But I think people are resonating well with it and I wonder if the current resurgence of popularity of the genre isn't thanks to CP2077 alone.
I think you've made some good observations. I've always had the impression that Cyberpunk is a fringe genre, despite the fact that some of the most high quality IP's out there are Cyperpunk. I'm thinking about Blade Runner, Ghost in The Shell, Akira and Deus Ex. You also have great animes like Vexille and Appleseed which draws heavily on Cyberpunk themes. I find it strange that Cyberpunk hasn't been more populare in the West. In some sense I'm actually happy about it, because I don't want big Hollywood studios to dumb down the genre or render it devoid of any substance. Cyberpunk is actually suited to be a fringe genre.
I care for GITS more than for any other fictional universe or IP. That's why I'm worried about this.
I'm also worried about the new live action GITS movie. I don't even know if I want to see it.
What else is new? While I tend to agree that many of what I personally refer to as "munchkins" often seem to fit that stereotype (all to well in some cases) most "serious" fans tend to be quite to opposite. Heck, just look at some of the discussions that take place in these forums ... posts involving anthropology, metallurgy, physics etc. are hardly uncommon. And the best Magna often touches on topics most live-action stuff won't touch.
Many people in the anime and gaming community are very intelligent and insightful people. Gaming in particular has been given a bad name, sadly. Like wtih most things unfamiliar or new, people won't bother trying to understand it. They will more likely just accept the prevailing narrative that gamers are losers who don't have a life.
Stereotypes are for lazy gonkers.
Last edited: