Finally to all the book elitists this is a game forum and in the end a lot of us are discussing a character by what is shown in the game. So just do not give me book evidence as that does not matter in our situation much since we talking about a rpg not books. Cause books in simpler terms can be considered a set point of view, games allow different people to have different point of views with their own choices.
If you want o base choices based on books then do that in the books forums, in the end there are quite majo differences between the two. The whole point of amnesia is a chance to start fresh. You want the past and feel thats is only way good for you but i find it to be a narrowminded point of view. I will judge a game character by what was shown in the game.
So some like Triss some like Yen and that is completely subjective
We just share points of views here. If you don't like people talking about the books why not just ignoring them? Imo the books make the discussion only richer and deeper and enhances the array of possible points of views. It's interesting to see how people see these characters differently, based on different knowledge, priorities and personal feelings. Why cutting that down?
But I agree that we should avoid trying to convince other people from our own point of view at all costs and sometimes in an arrogant way. Sharing points of views is fine but mocking people for various reasons is not.